MusicSmiles.com
The Worlds of Gilbert and Sullivan

A Nice Dilemma
Home

 

Up
Trial by Village!
Love-sick Boy
All Hail Great Judge!
Judge's Song
I Love Him
Oh Gentlemen Listen!
A Nice Dilemma

 

This wonderful and intricate piece is sometimes referred to as a Quartet and Chorus; at other times a Sextet and Chorus; and sometimes delicately as a Sestet and Chorus! Whatever its title (and it is a sure bet that G&S didn't give it one) it is a superb musical gem.

You will probably need access to the Vocal Score to follow all the parts. Why not get a copy from your local library? It's worth it! Or, if you prefer, just listen to the weaving of the music in this MusicSmiles arrangement, and imagine them trying to unravel the court-case quandary. It's a hoot!

A Nice Dilemma

Judge: A nice dilemma we have here,
That calls for all our wit,
For al our w . .i . . t:

Counsel: And at this stage,
It don't appear
That we can set . . tle it.

Defendant: If I to wed the girl am loth -
A breach 'twill surely be,

Plaintiff: And if he goes and marries both -
It counts as Burglaree.

Above Quartet + Usher & Foreman in harmony:

A nice dilemma we have here
 - - - - - - - - - - -

Above Sextet plus SATB Chorus in harmony:

A nice dilemma we have here
That calls for all our wit
 - - - - - - - - - - -
 - - - - - - - - - - -
That calls for all our . . wit

Usher: Silence in Court, silence in Court!

Can you hear the Usher trying to restore some sort of order to the rather unruly scene? In the end it all resolves itself in a rather surprising way, but not before audience (and cast) have had a great deal of musical fun! We hope you have enjoyed our Village Presentation of Gilbert & Sullivan's Trial by Jury

 

Like to return to Trial by Jury now . . .?

 


To search for an article in our special MusicSmiles Contents table

< < < Click Wise Owl's book < < < 

 

If you quote or print anything from this Web-site please add a link to MusicSmiles.com in your Web-site. Thanks.

© Music arranged and 'performed' by Dr J Eric Ashton

Copyright © Dr J Eric Ashton 27 September 2010 . All Rights Reserved.

This site was last updated on 27 September 2010 .

 

( Click number to view statistics > > >). Scribe thanks all our  223,547 MusicSmiles visitors up to beginning of September, 2010. 

You may find our special effects work best with Microsoft Internet Explorer